The HSA Account You Have But Probably Aren’t Using Right

By Andrew Langdon, CFP®, CSLP®, EA, MBA

Open enrollment lands in most people’s inboxes sometime in October, gets filed somewhere between “I’ll deal with this later” and the actual deadline, and then gets clicked through in fifteen minutes just to get it done. Benefits decisions are genuinely confusing, and if nothing catastrophic happened with your coverage last year, it’s hard to feel motivated to dig in.

So this isn’t an article about how to pick a health plan — that depends on your family’s specific situation, your healthcare utilization, your risk tolerance, and a bunch of variables I don’t know from here. But if you’re enrolled in a High-Deductible Health Plan and have access to a Health Savings Account, there’s a reasonable chance you’re leaving one of the better tools in the tax code sitting mostly unused. That’s what I want to talk about.

What most people actually do with their HSA

My wife and I had an HSA before we had kids, back before I was working in financial planning. We chose the HDHP partly because my employer was contributing to the HSA, which made the decision easier — essentially free money toward our deductible. But we still used the account the way most people use it: as a slightly more tax-efficient way to pay for doctor’s visits and prescriptions. When we moved to a PPO plan after our first child, the balance was pretty much gone. Looking back, that was the wrong approach, and honestly, I didn’t know enough at the time to do it differently.

The thing I see most often now working with veterinarians is a similar pattern: an HSA sitting at whatever the administrator defaulted it to, usually cash, earning close to nothing, with no investing happening at all. Most HSA platforms allow you to invest the balance — typically anything above $1,000 — in a menu of funds similar to what you’d find in a 401(k). A lot of people don’t know this, and I’m not sure the administrators do a great job of making it obvious.

The way an HSA is actually supposed to work

The real value of an HSA, if you can swing it, isn’t as a spending account for current medical costs. It’s as a long-term investment account that happens to have the best tax treatment of any account in existence.

Contributions are pre-tax (or deductible if you’re contributing directly rather than through payroll). The balance grows tax-free. Withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are tax-free. That triple tax treatment doesn’t exist anywhere else in the tax code — not in a 401(k), not in a Roth IRA, nothing else combines all three.

The strategy that takes full advantage of it looks like this: contribute the maximum, invest the balance in something broadly diversified, and pay your actual medical expenses out of pocket from cash flow. Let the HSA compound untouched for as long as possible. In retirement, when healthcare costs are highest and your other income sources may be more limited, you’ve got a tax-free pool of money specifically available for medical expenses.

There are some particularly useful applications in retirement that most people haven’t thought about. HSA funds can be used to pay premiums for Medicare and other health insurance if you’re retired — which is significant for anyone looking to retire before age 65 and bridge the gap to Medicare coverage. Long-term care insurance premiums are also an eligible expense. And if you get to 65 and the balance is larger than your medical expenses require, you can withdraw funds for any purpose and simply pay ordinary income tax on it at that point, the same as a traditional IRA distribution. Worst case, it’s a traditional IRA. Best case, it’s tax-free medical spending for decades.

The student loan angle most veterinarians miss

This one doesn’t get talked about enough. For veterinarians on an income-driven repayment plan, HSA contributions reduce your Adjusted Gross Income, which is the income figure used to calculate your monthly payment. Putting $9,000 into an HSA under family coverage doesn’t just lower your taxes — it directly lowers your IDR payment for the year. It’s essentially doing two things at once, and for someone carrying significant student debt early in their career, that’s not a small thing.

A few practical notes

For 2027, the contribution limits are $4,500 for individual coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, with an additional $1,000 catch-up for anyone 55 or older. It’s worth noting that “family” coverage for HSA purposes simply means you plus at least one other person on the plan — it doesn’t require covering an entire household. A single veterinarian adding a spouse or one dependent qualifies for the family limit. If your employer contributes to your HSA, that counts toward the same cap — it’s a combined limit, not additive, so it’s worth knowing what your employer is putting in before you set your own contribution.

If your HSA contributions don’t run through payroll — which is common for practice owners or anyone buying their own health insurance — you can still contribute directly and deduct it on Form 8889 when you file in April. It’s not as seamless as a payroll deduction, but the tax treatment is identical and it’s worth doing.

And if you currently have an HSA balance sitting in cash, the single most impactful thing you can do this week is log in, check whether investing is available above whatever threshold your administrator requires, and actually move it into something. It takes about ten minutes and it’s probably the highest-value ten minutes you’ll spend on your finances this month.

Why I wish I’d known this sooner

I can’t get back the years my wife and I spent using our HSA as a checking account for copays, but it’s made me a lot more direct with clients about getting this right from the start. The math on a maxed-out, invested HSA over a twenty or thirty year career is genuinely significant — and the math on one that’s been sitting in a default cash position is a reminder that good intentions aren’t the same as good outcomes.

If you have an HDHP and an HSA, open enrollment season is a natural moment to check whether you’re contributing the maximum and whether the balance is actually invested. Both are worth confirming before the enrollment window closes.

If any of this raises questions about your own situation, feel free to reach out at andrew@vetworthfinancial.com.